Thursday, April 30, 2015

Brick by Brick; Saving Madison Street

Madison and  US 6 / Market street



What is happening to Madison Street? 
The Madison Street restoration project is currently underway.  Read on to learn more about the scope of the project and the history behind it.

The History
When Nappanee was platted on December 12, 1874 eight streets were indicated and named, they remain the same today.  Main, Market, Clark, Locke, Lincoln, Walnut, Elm and Madison.  Aside from Main and Market, all these streets existed only on paper at the time that the lots were sold. Most "streets" were covered in timber or were soggy with patches of cattails and swamp. 

The growth of Nappanee was rapid and in the early days of Nappanee the streets were hardly what we today would consider passable. They were dirt with stones, roots and even stumps in some of the side streets.  Not to mention the puddles, ruts, tracks and so much manure! The dust that a horse and rig would kick up was only relieved when the streets were mud from the rain and snow.  Wagons pulling loads from the railroad would sometimes get stuck in the mud on the way out of town. 

In 1884 over 1000 wagon loads of gravel were dumped in the streets and graded up to the center of the streets.  But it helped little, The News in 1899 reported "Below this three or four inches of mud and manure there seems to be a good foundation of gravel."

In 1899 the Town Board was petitioned for brick or paved streets. It was 1907 before they began. In 1908 they began laying brick. For concrete base, bricks, gutters and curbs for Main and Market the entire cost was $78.827.45 




The Bricks 
Many of the bricks in Nappanee's oldest landmarks were made here in Nappanee.  In 1879, a brick yard was set up between North Main and Clark Streets. Clay for the bricks came from the North Clark Street vicinity.  One of several brick plants on record made the bricks for the school house and for Nappanee's first brick house in 1879.  Delotter and Mellinger Company began the manufacture of bricks in 1884. Most of the buildings that were built from that time on were of Delotter and Mellinger bricks. They were the largest brick company in Northern Indiana, in 1891 over one million bricks came from their kilns. 

Brick was the material of choice for street construction for a time, through the 1920s and up until World War II.  Bricks, however durable they are, have to be laid by hand, one by one, Asphalt and concrete are cheaper and smoother so naturally they have emerged as the common material for most streets.  


Brent Warren looks at plans for the project



The Project
In Nappanee, we have but one street of brick left.  A portion of one of Nappanee's original streets, Madison Street between Marion and Market remains brick.It is listed on the National Register of Historic Places as the East Side Historic District, Roughly bounded by Market, Main, John, and Summit Streets.  The street is dotted with stately old homes that tell of our history.
Though the brick itself has withstood the test of time, the street is warped, sagging and wavy and does not match up with the paved streets that it intersects. It can make for a bumpy ride or worse.

Over 26 years ago, when Hartman Street was paved, the curb was taken out on Madison Street as well. Thanks to the community the street was not paved over and talks began on how to preserve and maintain the brick street.  


Brent Warren, Nappanee's Street Superintendent remembers hearing former city employee, Sam Adams, discuss the project in 2001 when Brent first joined the department.  Brent said, "I remember Sam talking about doing it a block at a time."
It was most likely the cost that made the project take a back burner time and time again over the years.  The city started setting funds aside for the project years ago.

In November 2014 the city put out a request for proposals for the work, plans drawn up by Commonwealth, to be completed in 2015. In December 2014, the city awarded the project to HRP out of South Bend. They will remove all the bricks, palletize them, bring the sub grade up to the existing curb height and then re-lay the bricks.  They are also cutting the sidewalks to open them for new ADA compliant crosswalks.  

Phase one began on April 13.  Phase One includes Market to the south side of Centennial.  Phase Two is Centennial North to Marion Street.  The contract states that they have 120 days from April 1 to have substantial completion.  This means that by the end of July the work should be finished. Warren has reported that “the contractor is doing his best to keep either Centennial or Walnut Street open at all times."  Of course this is only an ideal projection, a project like this has many things that can come up unexpected. Warren said that " one of the biggest challenges is you never know what you are going to come across...what could be buried under there for nearly a century." 




Check back for updates on the progress of Saving Madison Street.

If you have Madison Street  memories, historical documents, or old pictures that you would like to share please send them to rockistillson72@gmail.com  




Thursday, April 16, 2015

What are we Preserving?

At one of my first meetings after being appointed by Mayor Thompson to the Historic Preservation Commission in 2014 I had to ask, “what exactly is historic preservation?”  Traditionally,  the focus and mission is to champion the protection of historic buildings, neighborhoods, architecture and landmarks but historic preservation is more than saving old buildings!   

Preserving our past by keeping and using old buildings and places is beneficial in so many ways to the people who call Nappanee home today. The historic aesthetic of Nappanee reflects the old fashioned charm and simple integrity that characterizes our community. These old places are not just beautiful, they tell our of our economic, cultural, educational and inspirational legacies - which quite literally makes us who we are. The deeper I delve into our local history the more connected I become with the people who walked these streets before us. I find myself craning my neck  to get a better look at a house that I have drove by thousands of times but have just learned the significance of its past. I have found the historical facts come alive when I am able to link them with physical places or artifacts.  Having those reminders of our past inspires a sense of continuity, identity and belonging.

Some have a hard time with the cost of preservation.  Many studies show the positive impact of historic preservation on the economy.  The national trust website shares 12 areas of economic benefit that have been documented. Property value, environmental impact, downtown revitalization, heritage tourism and social impact are all included.  It is silly to think that any study could show the full value of  utilizing and preserving these old places and our history.  That would be like Randall Mason said “calculating the incalculable, or pricing the priceless.”1

My hope is that you will take the time to recognize the past, the next time you drive through town on U.S. 6, walk through the historic neighborhoods or as you shop downtown that you will take the time to look at Nappanee’s skyline. Take a moment to hunt for the pieces of history that remain in plain view.  I also hope that you will take another moment to wonder; to contemplate those that built, shopped, worked and lived here in the past.

In the first year of my service on our town’s commission I have come to believe that historic preservation should not be defined and/or confined by bureaucratic perceptions or economics rather we should look at historic preservation as an ethic – a belief that history plays an important role in our lives today and in our communities sustainability for tomorrow. A community that respects its history respects itself.

1.Mason, Randall. “Economics and Historic Preservation: A Guide and Review of the Literature.” (The Brookings Institution, 2005).

Wednesday, April 1, 2015

Nappanee Trivia #1

1. What does the E stand for in E. Newcomer and Son?
2. How did the snowy weather effect the town of Locke in the winter of 1876?
3. What group of quilting activists said "Agitate, Educate, Legislate"?
4. What notorious criminal caused a bank in Nappanee to install a new alarm in the 1930s? ...
5. What store was billed as a triple store in downtown Nappanee?
6. How did Ed Arch Sr. deliver mail in 1908?
7. What sound sometimes scared cows and made country kids squeal in delight?
8. What did Nappanee have an abundance of at the time it was platted that shaped the future of its industry?
9. How much candy would a quarter buy in 1899?



Those that attended Night at the Museum in October 2014 have an advantage.  All the answers could have been learned the answers to these and other fun bits of Nappanee history were told in the living history event.